marcopolis's musings

    • Edit
    • Delete
    • Tags
    • Autopost

    On the right to peaceful protest: some video footage you might not have seen from the weekend

    I'm finding it hard to stay concentrated on work this morning.  It all seems so banal after the violation of democracy and free speech I just witnessed in my city.  So, some thoughts. And, then, I'll get back to work.

    I really wanted to go down to the protests yesterday to take pictures and video.  I'm glad I didn't, and I'm sad that I didn't.

    What kept me away was fear of the police, not the protesters.  This strikes me as an unfortunate thing, a bizarre thing, an enraging thing. 

    Afraid of the police.  It seems unbelievable.

    In the end, great instincts...

    An Overview

    Police brutality and oppression with impunity occurred this weekend in my city, which no longer feels like my city.  I'm disgusted, I'm emotional, I'm angry, I'm sad.  I actually feel like crying as I write this and reflect on the impact this weekend has had on my psyche.

    But, mostly, I'm really, really angry. 

    The irony with all of this is that, in this day and age of everyone with a camera, everyone with access to social media, that the police actually seemed to think they could act with total impunity.  I'm hopeful that this might be a tipping point for people to not accept this in our society. I'm not naively optimistic, but I refuse to believe that we are raising our son in an environment where we fear police presence and that we can no longer trust them to actually "serve and protect" us, that we cannot voice our dissent on our public streets.  I've never truly been politicized, but after watching this disgusting scene unfold over the weekend, unedited by the press and the powers that be, brought to you by the people who were peacefully protesting, on all of our behalf, I need to figure out a way to start taking tangible, practical, non-violent action.  Although the critical cleansing is starting to happen in the press, I hope it cannot be erased, and the current immediate, embarrassed reactions by some major media figures is heartening.  Our city leaders, on the other hand, continue to embarras...

    Let me say up front, I, obviously, do not support the wanton destruction of property by a few "protesters."  But, we must ask ourselves, as this rolls out, how is that a few police cars were "left" in the path of Black Bloc protesters. How interesting that the fires were not immediately put out, but left to burn for all the world to see.  How bizarre that, just before all of this, hundreds of riot police set upon peaceful protesters in the "designated free speech zone" and drove them out (see more below).  How strange that, as one tweeter put it most succinctly, ''How were 19000 cops unable to control 100 anarchists?''. How interesting that police brutality ramped up after the events of Saturday afternoon, when the "rioters", not protesters, these "organized anarchists" (oxymoron much?) that the police continue to tell us they were completely prepared for, were left utterly to their own devices, to do exactly what the police told us they would do.

    I'm not a conspiracy theorist, but, damn...

    I offer you some of the scenes that I "witnessed" online this weekend, and some articles worth reading.

    What We Saw This Weekend, and Should Have Been Allowed to See More Of

    Let me start you off with this light video of our peaceful protesters in action:

      
    "You're sexy, you're cute, take off your riot suit!"  Awesome! :-)

    Then, wet your appetite with this. You may find it hard to watch more after the first link, but please continue below.

    Compelling Video Footage

    Be wary of singing O Canada in public this week...

    <p>Peaceful G20 protest at Queen & Spadina from Meghann Millard on Vimeo


    Some of the video below is disturbing. Maybe you don't want to watch it, but please do.  It is important that we are aware of exactly what happened over the weekend.

    Apart from the conveniently placed burning car imagery you'll find across the mainstream media today, it's worth straying into the realm of citizen journalism for unedited footage where you can make up your own mind about what you see...
      
    I found an interesting/disturbing image on the Star site http://thestar.blogs.com/.a/6a00d8341bf8f353ef0133f1e00371970b-700wi.
     
    6a00d8341bf8f353ef0133f1e00371970b-700wi
     
    If you wonder if this attack was "provoked", watch this video
     
    .
     
    Seems like unnecessary roughness to me.
     
    For me, along with the links above, here is some defining imagery from the weekend...
     
    Some great tweets from others:
     
    ''How were 19000 cops unable to control 100 anarchists?''
     

    "Is no one on the G20 police force trained in conflict resolution? Nobody trained in how to rachet *down* the tension?"

     
    "Let this be the last time out-of-town cops are deployed in Toronto."

    Toronto G20 - Riot Police Shoot Smoke Bombs into Crowd - You've probably seen this, but listen to the commentary - there was absolutely no provocation for this.  This was confirmed in other reports and longer videos showing the cop with the gun jump in front of a female protester, aiming point blank at her.


    Interesting video footage of this scene from someone who lived in the area, from their porch (yeah, police fired in a residential area...)


    http://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=1512684781074&ref=mf (requires login)
     
    Ask yourself why is person at 2 minute mark in the vid below arbitrarily grabbed, thrown to ground, arrested? No possible provocation.  There's footage of scenes like this everywhere.

    G20 Summit Toronto - Queen's Park #5 
     
     
    The plain clothes, utterly unidentifiable "cops" in the video below are a bit scary to see.  What "threat" were they countering?
     
    A defining picture of police attitude to peaceful protesters (yeah, that's a cop with no obvious police identification, which you'll see more of in the video below):
     
    Att3b626
     
    G20 Toronto Protest plainclothes cops arresting a dude / scary cop lady
     

    If you want to see the police presence build up at the "designated free speech zone" at Queen's Park, where no violent protest was occurring, check out further videos of the "Roman empire-esque centurions" approach (a 7-part series of videos): 

    G20 Summit Toronto - Queen's Park #3 
     

    G20 Summit Toronto - Queen's Park #4
    (check the 30 second mark for their "march" into the park in the distance)

    Violent Police Arrests Queens Park Toronto G20 June 26
     

    Kind of interesting...  There should be lots more of this citizen journalism coming out, including much footage of the actual, peaceful protests that did occur before police attacked.

    Some Useful Reading

    A great start to your reading today, this Toronto Star editorial:

    G20 editorial: Brutal spectacle failed a city and its people
    http://www.thestar.com/opinion/editorials/article/829601--g20-editorial-brutal-spectacle-failed-a-city-and-its-people

     
    Also, ask yourself how well the "Miami Model" described in this article applies to Toronto.
    http://www.thestar.com/article/828876--porter-when-police-stick-to-phony-script

    To top it off, Amnesty Canada's call for an independent review:

    http://www.amnesty.ca/blog_post2.php?id=1812
     
    And, if you're so inclined to join:
     
    New Facebook group: Canadians Demanding a Public Inquiry into Toronto G20
    http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=135629036463012
     
    Media_httpmarcopoliso_gdqar

    • 28 June 2010
    • Views
    • 4 Comments
    • Permalink
    • Tweet
    • 4 responses
    • Like
    • Comment
    almost 2 years ago Marco Campana responded:
    Marco Campana
    A response from someone I emailed this message to:

    "For me, the thing that's pissing me off most (and like you, my response is both angry and sad) is that it is so terribly clear that all that security, all those cops, were NOT here to protect me, and you, and the kind of life we ostensibly lead in a democracy.

    Clearly we've failed as a society when we all feel so insecure that we collectively find it reasonable to abandon our downtown for three days out of fear of a) the security apparatus (secret regulations? WTF?) and b) 100 utter assholes who like to break stuff. And then it all unfolds as if scripted, teenagers get strip-searched, goons in and out of uniform run wild, and the people with valid protests never get heard."

    almost 2 years ago meznor (Twitter) responded:
    1313946320248_normal
    I wasn't in the downtown core, either, and it's a good thing I wasn't.

    I initially thought $1 billion was to protect the summit leaders - the men and women who were shaping economic policy and making supposedly big decisions about the future of our global economic recovery.

    Watching the news, and reading the tweets and blogs, it looks like $1 billion was to protect us from ourselves.

    Yet when I reflect on everything leading up to this - the various groups and people who said it was a bad idea to have it in Toronto; the announcement of $1 billion of taxpayer money in security, an obscene amount compared to previous summits; the "fake lake" coverage by media & opposition parties alike; the $5 million fence in the heart of our city that disrupted ordinary people from their jobs and lives, and forced businesses to shut their doors and seek cover; the excessive police force who outnumbered and out-weaponed anything any peaceful protester could have possibly been carrying to be used as a potential "weapon"; the extension of a law that would give police the right to arrest and search a person refusing to show ID without any cause, directly in violation of our Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and passed surreptitiously "like a mushroom growing under a rock"...

    ...it all seems like we (my city, and the people who went to demonstrate) were set up to behave badly, to justify the price tag.

    I'm still trying to figure out... why Toronto? Why not Ottawa? Why not Lake Louise, Alberta? Why not some remote island that had a natural security perimeter? Why in the biggest city in Canada, and in one of the most diverse and politically charged centres of the country, and in one of the most dynamic and beautiful neighbourhoods that will take a lot of money to repair in the aftermath?

    Who is to blame here? I don't blame police for doing their jobs... I blame them for going to far. I don't blame even the anarchists who caused trouble and were allowed to destroy our city... I blame the leaders who were safe and sound in their bubble, sipping on wine and cocktails and eating fine cuisine while the chaos broke out all around them, while the men and women who normally protect us became enemies, and ordinary people because vicitms of the most massive arrests in Canadian history.

    I blame Stephen Harper and his arrogance, and his complete disregard for the people he is supposed to be representing. And I hope this finally marks the end of him and his regime, that time and again has corroded our democracy. There are parts of the world that have no idea what democracy is... we're supposed to be the example. This weekend, I feel like a lot of us woke up to just a very small taste what it could be like if we lived in those parts of the world... I sincerely hope we don't forget it...

    almost 2 years ago Marco Campana responded:
    Marco Campana
    @meznor, thanks very much for your comment. I think you sum up how I feel like I can no longer be complacent, with:

    "There are parts of the world that have no idea what democracy is... we're supposed to be the example. This weekend, I feel like a lot of us woke up to just a very small taste what it could be like if we lived in those parts of the world... I sincerely hope we don't forget it..."

    almost 2 years ago Marco Campana responded:
    Marco Campana
    Another email response:

    I haven't quite been able to put into words how I've been feeling about all this, so I really appreciated you expressing your thoughts & providing information that seem to represent the feelings of many right now.

    I too have been appalled by the events of this past week, and as I was involved with the peaceful protest & rally on Saturday (a marshall actually), I was so disappointed that the media chose to focus on the acts of violence caused by a small group of people and not the outrageous actions of the police towards peaceful protesters. Not to mention the complete ignorance of the large successful march through the streets of Toronto, or how us marshalls worked with participants to continually shift the attention away from the black bloc antics, heckling, chaotic displays of anger, and heavy mob squad presence, back to the focus & purpose of the March. But we'll never hear praise for the 10,000 peaceful marchers or the thousands of others who made a statement by singing, sitting in, recording or just simply participating with their presence without breaking the law or resorting to violence. Lastly, I'm stuggling with the contradiction of my respect for the police and my shattered faith in their actions (and our system) for not protecting us from those instigating the violence, for their apathy towards the black bloc tactics and utter disregard for the safety of Torontonians while the 'real' criminal acts were taking place.

    You said it - we can be grateful that social media has allowed us to expose incidents that would otherwise be hidden. It would seem as though the police are either naive to, or uninformed on this new wave of technology that could hold them accountable. Perhaps this is just one more added benefit of utilizing social media!

  • Marco Campana's Space

    I live in Toronto. You can follow me on Twitter @marcopolis.

    Archive

    2011 (2)
    April (2)
    2010 (8)
    July (4)
    June (4)
    2009 (1)
    September (1)
  • About Marco Campana

    I live in Toronto. You can follow me on Twitter @marcopolis.

  • Subscribe via RSS
  • Follow Me

      metaweblog

Theme created for Posterous by Obox